|
The Bully-Victim Relationship: What We've Learned So Far
By Marty Tombari, Ph.D.
Senior Research Analyst
and
Laurie Bennett
Research Assistant
Under a three-year grant from the U.S. Justice Department's Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (OJJDP), NCSE is studying the linkages between bullying and in-school and out-of-school adjustment outcomes, such as truancy, dropping out, suspensions, expulsions, and delinquency. We are in the first year of the grant, in the midst of a review of the extensive research literature studying the bully-victim relationship. Below is a brief summary of some of what we have learned so far.
What is the nature of the bully-victim relationship?
Researchers agree that the essential features of a bully-victim relationship include: An intentional aggressive harmful act that is repeated a number of times and is part of a relationship characterized by an imbalance of power between the bully and the victim.
How many children are involved in bully-victim relationships?
Estimates of the extent of bully-victim relationships in school settings vary depending on whether you ask the bullies or the victims to report about their experiences, or whether you ask others (teachers, parents, peers) to identify who the bullies and the victims are.
What are some of the psychological/behavioral consequences of being part of a bully-victim relationship?
The psychological and behavioral consequences for the victims involved in this relationship appear to be more damaging than are those for the bullies.
- Although some of the early bully studies showed that bullies experience low self-esteem, depression and loneliness, more recent studies suggest that the psychological profiles of bullies are relatively benign.
- Victims are at risk for low self-esteem, low school engagement, school avoidance, lower school achievement, learned helplessness, and depression.
What makes it likely that a child will become part of a bully-victim relationship?
Some early bully-victim relationship research focused on identifying family factors and personality characteristics of bullies and victims, which put them at risk for being a bully or a victim. More recent research has focused on aspects of the school and classroom environment that increase the likelihood of children becoming bullies and victims. Some of the findings from this research are:
- Children who come to kindergarten lonely, withdrawn, or aggressive may be rejected by their classmates.
- Some rejected children become targets of bullies and experience negative outcomes like abuse and exclusion.
- Not all lonely, withdrawn or aggressive children become victims or bullies in early elementary school.
- The quality and nature of their first and subsequent peer experiences are principally responsible for later peer maltreatment.
Can children who are part of the bully-victim relationship ever break out of it?
A significant number of children are engaged in this kind of relationship. Whether they break out of it may depend on whether...
- Victims develop other friendships
- Victims acquire certain behavioral and psychological coping strategies
- School personnel intervene
- Both bullies and victims change where they go to school and with whom they associate at school.
Can changes in school climate eliminate the bully-victim relationship?
Evidence is slowly accumulating that schools can reduce substantially the frequency of bully-victim relationships. There are several evidence-based programs available to schools that, if implemented properly, reduce incidences of bullying in both the short and long-term.
What needs further study?
Some studies suggest that factors occurring after a child has been victimized may have a significant impact on that child's subsequent school achievement, engagement, and/or adjustment. Such factors may include:
We believe that this area merits further study as a possibly fertile field for future interventions leading to more positive outcomes for children for whom bully-victim relationships have been a problem.
Truancy Prevention Contest Awards Announced
By Judith Martinez NCSE Director
and
Gretchen Erickson Research Associate
In April 2006, NCSE hosted a national truancy prevention contest to find out what materials communities are using to support truancy prevention and to promote the importance of school attendance. Special thanks to all who participated. Entries were judged based on originality, creativity, and marketing appeal. The judges represented juvenile courts, community programs, high school students, truant officers, and social workers/psychologists.
Awards were given in the following areas:
1. Community campaign
2. School district/area-wide campaigns
3. Individual school/community campaigns
In addition, two Judge's Awards were given (Straight-Up award, and Most Eye-Catching.). Here are the award winners in the top three categories…
Community Category - The award goes to Richard Williamson, LMSW-AP from Watauga, TX. His entry included hallway posters that can also be featured on websites. Visit www.truants.org to view the posters developed by a former truant (see the following poster).

School District/School Area Category - The award goes to the State's Attorney's Office, 4th Judicial Circuit of Florida in Jacksonville. This entry included brochures titled: 'Count Me In for Learning'. They are part of a public awareness campaign to stress the importance of attending school regularly. There are two versions of the brochure: one is for elementary children, the other is for secondary children.
Individual School and Community Category - The award goes to Evansville-Vanderburgh School Corporation in Indiana. The entry represented a local 'Attendance Awareness Month' event. It included hallway posters and T-shirts with the message, 'Everybody in School Everyday.' A 4th grade student inspired the 2006 poster. Two versions of this poster follow.


Click here to view all the award winning posters.
Return to the Index of this Issue
|